History has taught us that Major League umpires must be dragged kicking and screaming to help make changes in the game of baseball, and history is about to repeat itself this fall.
A series of blown calls and controversies have led baseball to the cusp of instant replay, a form of technology used by all three other major sports in this country. Commissioner Bud Selig and his bumbling cronies are fully aware that scrutiny of every called ball or strike would ruin the game, so they favor a limited use of replay that would judge home runs and fair or foul balls. You would think that the umpires, men who insist that they agonize at night over missed calls and make their best efforts to get it right every time, would embrace such an idea.
You would be wrong. That same group of umpires boycotted a conference call on Tuesday with baseball's management, a petty decision made because of their concerns about what World Umpires Association chief Lamell McMorris called "procedural issues". McMorris is concerned about how it will look if umpires are forced to leave the field to view replays or if they must consult replay officials in a booth somewhere in the park, worried that the process will become a running joke and will be discredited if it's not absolutely seamless.
McMorris' concerns would be valid if he wasn't trying to defend one of the most bull-headed groups of men in professional sports. Major League umpires have earned their reputations as cantankerous at best and downright bitter at worst, a stodgy group of aging dinosaurs who are more concerned about protecting themselves than the game that they arbitrate. This same crowd had their ranks cut to shreds when their former general counsel, Richie Phillips, suggested that they resign en masse in a fight for enhanced benefits in 1999. Major League Baseball accepted the bulk of the resignations, signaling a new era in which umpires would not be able to hold the players and owners hostage anymore.
Even Selig knew that this was his chance to take command, and he made the surviving umpires come crawling back to cut a deal. Selig quickly abolished the exclusive American and National league crews, creating one large pool to work both leagues. He hired new blood that was trained differently in the minor leagues, men who were encouraged to get together on the field and sometimes overrule a call if they saw something different than the original ruling. Just picture the A-Rod purse-slapping incident against Bronson Arroyo or Mark Bellhorn's three-run homer that almost wasn't in the 2004 ALCS -- both of those calls were initially blown until heads came together and discussions were had.
Veteran umpires feel that even suggesting a call has been missed is some form of disrespect, and that's at the root of what is going on right now. This is their one last grasp at total control of the game, even if they miss a crucial home run like Derek Jeter's pop-up to right that Richie Garcia bungled into a Jeffrey Maier-aided start of the latest New York Yankees' dynasty in 1996. They rebelled at the thought of Ques-Tec, the camera-aided strike zone that was being used to grade their performance in 2004. They absolutely hate the overhead camera angle that FOX uses during its playoff coverage, an angle that exposes a plate umpire for having a zone as wide as Andruw Jones. Umpires are against anything that will shed light on their mistakes -- replay might as well be the sun hitting a dark basement for the first time in years. The glow that will follow will make the game better and send the Draculas in black on the bases back into their coffins where they belong.
Syndication